top of page


I love to decorate cookies - it's a wonderful creative outlet, but what I love most are the reactions from customers and making sure their experience is a positive one. There is no better way to learn about customer experience than to read reviews. Here are just a few and I hope they give you a sense of the importance I place on a quality product and customer satisfaction. Thank you for supporting my small business and I hope to make something special for you soon!

- Jen Herman, Owner
Rolling Sugar Bakery, LLC


"Best cookies ever! The detail in the designs are unimaginable! I let Jen know we were looking for fire trucks, police cars, etc and what she came up with was so much better than I expected. And not to mention the taste of the cookies! Perfect softness to the cookie and sweetness of the icing!"

— Sarah S.

Reviewed May 2023


"The online ordering process was easy. The cookies looked great and the kids enjoyed them. Pickup was easy and ready on time. I would definitely use them again."

— Dave L.

Reviewed November 2023


"I've used Rolling Sugar Bakery many times now and plan to keep using them! I swear the cookies get cuter and cuter every time! I love the designs, Jenn has been flexible with my needs, and they come individually wrapped which is so nice!"

— Elayna R.

Reviewed Dec 2022


"These were the most beautiful, baby shower cookies I have ever seen. I saw them on the website and we had to have them for my daughters shower. They were ready on time, looked just like they did on the website and tasted great! What else could you ask for?"

— Carolyn S.

Reviewed July 2021

North Pole donut cookies

"Such darling cookies! I got donuts, paint an elf, pizza and hats with their names for my grandsons. Such a hit! The best decorating I’ve ever seen - even on cookie challenge shows on Food Network."

— Gayle E.

Reviewed Jan 2023

baseball birthday cookies

"Rolling Sugar Bakery made cookies for my son's first birthday party and they were perfect! I sent her some images of what I had in mind and she went above and beyond my expectations. They were also delicious. Highly recommend."

— Christina M.

Reviewed Aug 2022


"From placing the order to picking them up, every thing was perfect and my daughter loved them. She said they were the best ones she has had yet. Will order from you again."

— Melinda K.

Reviewed May 2022


"RollingSugar Bakery is fantastic! The taste, design, packaging, and overall quality is truly superior. We ordered ‘paint your own’ cookies for a birthday party and they made the best party favors! Highly recommend all things RollingSugar!"

— Jessica S.

Reviewed April 2021


"The cookies were Beautiful and tasted Awesome! Highly recommend this designer, she does an incredible job!"

— Charlene D.

Reviewed April 2022


"I ordered paint-your-own gingerbread men cookies for my preschool class. They were absolute perfection. Jen is so talented. She also made my cookies available for pickup early due to poor weather conditions. Above and beyond!"

— Lindsey T.

Reviewed Dec 2020


"Ordered the adorable pizza cookies for Valentine's Day gifts and they were such a hit. The attention to detail from the decoration on the cookie to the packaging is so well done. The owner communicated with me promptly whenever I had a question. To top it off, the cookies actually tasted delicious. Sometimes when you have food that is so elaborately decorated it doesn't always taste the best but these cookies were fantastic. Will definitely order again."

— Elizabeth S.

Reviewed Feb 2022


"Rolling Sugar Bakery made custom cookies for a baby shower I was hosting based off of a photo I shared through text. She listened to all my needs and the cookies were perfect. There were so many compliments on how cute and delicious the cookies were. Several people asked for contact information of the baker, which I was happy to share."

— Michelle P.

Reviewed March 2022

bottom of page